Super League-Premier League club comparison

After Widnes’ 12-18 victory last Thursday ended Wigan’s 21 month unbeaten Super League run at the DW Stadium comparisons between the Vikings and Leicester City have only continued to grow.

Even with Dennis Betts playing down similarities between his side and Claudio Ranieri’s Leicester the likeness does make you think if each Super League team where a Premier League side who would they be?

Castleford Tigers – Stoke City

Previously looked at as the ‘plucky underdog’ both Castleford and Stoke are trying to adjust to expectations following their recent success. In recent years Stoke have reached an FA Cup final and have played in Europe whilst Castleford earned a place in the Challenge Cup final in 2014 and competed in the ‘Super 8’s’.

However much like Stoke Castleford are bringing the best out of some very talented players. Luke Dorn, Ben Roberts, Luke Gale and Denny Solomona are all shining under Daryll Powell’s leadership and their continued success could see them bring in more high-profile names like the Potters have done in the Premier League.

Cas have been hit with a lot of injuries early on and they will have to show they have some squad depth and more than just a solid first seventeen something Stoke have struggled with at times.

Catalans Dragons – Everton

It seems everyone looks at Everton as if they have had a good season however inconsistency as seen them fall away from the European places and it always feels the same with the Catalans Dragons. Heading into the 2016 campaign many predicted the French side to do well this season but they’ve had a mixed start which has seen them struggle at home but win as many away games as they did all last season.

And while the Dragons home form will probably pick up it will only act as a cover for what will likely be another average season considering the names they’ve brought in. Names like Glenn Stewart, David Taylor and Willie Mason will take away from the results if they are poor.

Somehow I’m sure Catalans will lead us into believing they’ve had a hugely successful season when they finish just inside the top eight.

Huddersfield Giants – Crystal Palace

The Giants have been flying over the past few seasons but their significant slump in form at the beginning of this season is reminiscent of Palace’s fall down the Premier League table since the turn of the year. Paul Anderson’s side find themselves pinned to the bottom of the Super League table after only mustering one win from their first six games of the season.

Huddersfield have been plagued with injuries early on this season and really struggled when playmaker Danny Brough was out for two games. Brough’s absence in the Giants side leaves a noticeable gap in their attack something that Crystal Palace have had to come to terms with this season with striker Yannick Bolasie out for a large period of time.

It is still yet to be seen as to whether the Giants can turn their season around.

Hull FC – Manchester United

How many times over the past few pre-seasons have we heard “Hull FC are the team to watch this season”? Almost every time. Ever Since Fergie left Old Trafford we’ve heard the same about United “This will be the season they turn back to the United of old.” That has still yet to happen.

Hull FC have made many marquee acquisitions over the past few seasons with Hull bringing in Gareth Ellis, Leon Pryce and most recently Frank Pritchard but much like Angel Di Maria, Falcao and Memphis Depay none of them have made a huge impact. Much like United fans the Hull FC fans seem to be growing more and more frustrated with their failure to live up to expectations.

Already FC have shown inconsistency in the early weeks of the season it may just be another underwhelming season for Lee Radford’s men.

Hull KR – Newcastle United                          

Hull KR seem to be the side that season-by-season, week-by-week are slowly sliding into trouble just like the Toon have in the Premier League in recent times.

Since KR came up to the Super League their side has slowly begun to involve less and less home-grown talent and revolved around imported players in a similar fashion to Newcastle’s French overhaul. Both clubs seem to be in serious denial of the trouble they’re in and if they continue the way they are going they could well be playing in a different league come next season.

Rafa Benitez and James Webster have been brought in to steady the ships in recent weeks but it could be too much of a task for both men.

Leeds Rhinos – Chelsea

Well, I think the comparison here is easy to see. Leeds Rhinos were last season’s treble winners hailed as one of the best sides to ever grace Super League and much like Premier League champions Chelsea they’ve suffered a rapid fall from grace.

The Rhinos have struggled to come to terms with the departures of Jamie Peacock, Kevin Sinfield and Kylie Leuluia as well as injuries to key players such as new captain Danny McGuire. This has led them to have an extremely stuttered start to the season much like Chelsea suffered under Jose Mourinho when players like Diego Costa, Cesc Fabregas and Eden Hazard weren’t performing.

The arrival of Guus Hiddink has turned things around at Stamford Bridge and while it is highly unlikely that Brian McDermott will lose his role at Leeds he has a lot of work to do if the Rhinos are to retain their title.

Salford Red Devils – Liverpool

This comparison has very little to do with success and fan-base but more to do with absurd spending and transfer policies in recent times. When Dr Marwan Koukash came in and starting throwing his financial weight around most Red Devils fans thought it was the start of a new era and instead what they got was a bunch of players past their prime on a lot more money than they should be. As for Liverpool’s signing history just see – Andy Carroll, Dejan Lovren, Cristian Benteke.

Jurgen Klopp has already begun to make changes for the future at Anfield and this season Salford’s acquisitions also seem to be more targeted towards the future. Players like Robert Lui and Ben Murdoch-Masila are trying to make a name for themselves and could help Salford climb the Super League table.

Heading down a more youthful path may not work for the Red Devils immediately but it certainly gives them a better foundation than in previous seasons.

St Helens – Arsenal

Saints haven’t had a bad start to the campaign but as always it feels like they are missing something, nobody can put their finger on it, but there’s something not there. Another team who has been labelled with the same criticism is Arsenal who seemed to have bottled their best chance at winning the title in almost a decade.

Both sides have quality players but always seem to be hampered with injuries. Saints’ injury list over the last 4-5 seasons would most likely be longer than most Super League clubs combined, they almost have a squad of Abou Diaby’s. Kieran Cunningham is a St Helens legend much like Arsene Wenger at Arsenal but you feel with Cunningham doesn’t start to get it right he could follow in Wenger’s footsteps and the love from the fans could slowly fade away.

However I think it would be fair to say Saints stand a much better chance than Arsenal of winning some silverware at this stage.

Wakefield Wildcats – Sunderland

Wakefield were the first side to lose their coach this season when Brian Smith walked out and this has become something the Wildcats are all too familiar with James Webster also leaving last season.

One Premier League side who are accustomed to a managerial change or two are Sunderland who it seems every season bring a new man in and just about survive. Wakefield only just managed to win the Million Pound Game last season and in all honestly their squad hasn’t really improved much like Sunderland’s. Both sides have spent the last few seasons down the wrong end of the table and its only a matter of time before your luck runs out.

Both Chris Chester and Sam Allardyce are tasked with keeping their sides in the top flights of their respective sports but it could be a lot easier said than done.

Warrington Wolves – West Ham

Tony Smith’s side had a very difficult 2015 which saw them never really find any prolonged good form however this season they’ve come out flying winning all of their Super League games so far including an opening weekend win over treble winners Leeds Rhinos.

So why West Ham? Well West Ham did well last season but were also subject to some inconsistency. However this season they have improved under Slavan Bilic and they started the season in unbelievable form knocking off Manchester City, Liverpool and Arsenal all away from home. The Hammers flair players have stepped up when needed this season and this is something that Chris Sandow and Kurt Gidley have managed up to now for the Wolves.

West Ham look to be on the precipice of Champions League football for the first time in their history and a top four finish for Warrington would definitely be an improvement on last years campaign.

Widnes Vikings – Leicester

The fairy tale season that Leicester City have had thus far in the Premier League seems to have inspired Dennis Betts and the Widnes Vikings as they lead the Super League winning six of their seven games so far this season.

Kevin Brown has taken on the Riyad Mahrez role in this Widnes side providing the creativity and spark going forward which has resulted in numerous assists already. With Brown imitating the Mahrez role then winger and Super League top try-scorer Cory Thompson is Jamie Vardy. Thompson has already crossed for ten tries this season after going under the radar from all pundits and fans in pre-season.

Whether Widnes can maintain this form for the length that Leicester have is a different story however.

Wigan Warriors – Tottenham

Now I’m sure Wigan fans will question this comparison with “Tottenham, they’ve never won the Premier League?” Yes, I’ll accept that one main difference is the fact that Wigan have won the Super League on several occasions and Spurs are yet to win a Premier League but there is still a chance for them this season.

A solid campaign for Spurs has been centred on great defence and a fantastic home record which is identical to Wigan even if Widnes did end their unbeaten home Super League run last weekend. If you look at both sides they both possess a lot of talented English players with Wigan boasting Sam Tomkins, Michael McIlorum, Oliver Gildart, George Williams and many more. Spurs, likewise, like to use their home-grown talent in the form of Harry Kane, Dele Alli, Eric Dier and Danny Rose.

Tottenham may be pipped to the league title by Leicester but they have sustained a solid challenge all season and that is something Wigan would like to emulate.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s